| OT2 Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of OT2 period [45:00]. |
| [46:26] | Shot by NAZARETH Michaela Cushman, SAVE Ava Reynolds. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by NAZARETH Audra Mieczkowski [46:32]. |
| [46:46] | Shot by NAZARETH Hailey Dimao, SAVE Ava Reynolds. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| [48:44] | NAZARETH substitution: Hanna Barrett for Michaela Cushman. |
| [49:00] | Shot by HCFH2025 Hope Angioletti, SAVE Lauren Bachner. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Katelyn Klotz [49:00]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [50:26]. |
| [50:43] | Shot by HCFH2025 Katelyn Klotz, SAVE Lauren Bachner. |
| [50:43] | HCFH2025 Katelyn Klotz PENALTY STROKE GOAL. |
| Hartwick College 2, Nazareth 1 |
| [50:51] | NAZARETH substitution: Michaela Cushman for Kristina Fisher. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| [51:49] | Shot by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel WIDE. |
| [51:59] | HCFH2025 substitution: Erica Leeson for Dani Hand. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [52:55] | NAZARETH substitution: Kristina Fisher for Michaela Cushman. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [55:30] | GOAL by NAZARETH Isabel Porterfield. |
| Nazareth 2, Hartwick College 2 |
| [55:30] | NAZARETH substitution: MacKenzie Dixson for Hanna Barrett. |
| [55:30] | HCFH2025 substitution: Dani Hand for Caroline Aspuru. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [55:50] | NAZARETH substitution: Michaela Cushman for Hannah Janes. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [56:18]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [56:52]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [58:04] | Shot by NAZARETH Kristina Fisher, SAVE Ava Reynolds. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| [59:01] | HCFH2025 substitution: Caroline Aspuru for Erica Leeson. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [59:44]. |
| [59:52] | Shot by HCFH2025 Hope Angioletti, SAVE Lauren Bachner. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | End of period [60:00]. |