| OT Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of OT period [30:00]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by HUFH24 Adria Hartzler [31:06]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by HUFH24 Adria Hartzler [31:16]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by HUFH24 Adria Hartzler [31:31]. |
| [31:37] | GOAL by HUFH24 Ava Kramp, Assist by Jace Hunzinger. |
| Hartwick College 4, Houghton 1 |
| | *shot off of pas into circle |
| [32:42] | Shot by HCFH Ashley Tricarico BLOCKED. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [34:46] | HCFH substitution: Emily Holladay for Caroline Aspuru. |
| [35:20] | HCFH substitution: Makenzie Kensel for Makayla Bales. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [36:16] | HUFH24 substitution: Sara Carter for Bekah Davie. |
| [36:50] | HCFH substitution: Makayla Bales for Danielle Hand. |
| [37:16] | Shot by HCFH Ashley Tricarico, SAVE Annika Galen. |
| | Foul on Houghton. |
| [39:23] | HCFH substitution: Caroline Aspuru for Jessica Betts. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [41:34] | Shot by HCFH Makenzie Kensel WIDE. |
| [42:06] | HCFH substitution: Danielle Hand for Makayla Bales. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Houghton. |
| | Foul on Houghton. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH Ashley Tricarico [43:29]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by HUFH24 Adria Hartzler [44:33]. |
| [44:40] | Shot by HUFH24 Madison Gancasz, SAVE Ashley Luppens. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | End of period [45:00]. |