| OT Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of OT period [30:00]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [31:57] | Shot by HCFH2025 Caroline Aspuru, SAVE Parrinello, Morgan. |
| [32:01] | Shot by HCFH2025 Dani Hand, SAVE Parrinello, Morgan. |
| | Foul on St. John Fisher. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [33:01] | Shot by HCFH2025 Natalie O'Malley, SAVE Parrinello, Morgan. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by STJOHN McLaughlin, Avery [33:28]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by STJOHN McLaughlin, Avery [33:38]. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Penalty corner by STJOHN McLaughlin, Avery [33:48]. |
| [33:57] | Shot by STJOHN McPhee, Mary Kate DEFENSIVE SAVE by Mackenzie Hubbard. |
| [33:57] | GOAL by STJOHN Schirrmacher, Katie. |
| St. John Fisher 1, Hartwick College 1 |
| | *off defensive save |
| | Foul on St. John Fisher. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [34:36]. |
| [34:50] | GOAL by HCFH2025 Kendal Woolley. |
| Hartwick College 2, St. John Fisher 1 |
| | *in off deflection |
| [36:09] | STJOHN substitution: Current, Sam for Schirrmacher, Katie. |
| [36:09] | STJOHN substitution: Byrns, Sydney for Gregory, Morgan. |
| | Foul on St. John Fisher. |
| [39:17] | HCFH2025 substitution: Lexi Cheeseman for Dani Hand. |
| | Foul on St. John Fisher. |
| [41:54] | STJOHN substitution: Herbert, Leeah for Kauffman, Jordan. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [43:06] | Shot by HCFH2025 Lexi Cheeseman, SAVE Parrinello, Morgan. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [43:35] | HCFH2025 substitution: Dani Hand for Kendal Woolley. |
| | Foul on St. John Fisher. |
| | Foul on St. John Fisher. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [44:34]. |
| [44:46] | Shot by HCFH2025 Hope Angioletti, SAVE Parrinello, Morgan. |
| | End of period [45:00]. |