| OT Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of OT period [30:00]. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [30:26]. |
| [30:50] | Shot by HCFH2025 Kendal Woolley, SAVE Lauren Bachner. |
| [30:59] | Shot by HCFH2025 Makayla Bales DEFENSIVE SAVE by Avery Tanton. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Katelyn Klotz [31:09]. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [32:53]. |
| [32:56] | Shot by HCFH2025 Katelyn Klotz, SAVE Lauren Bachner. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Penalty corner by HCFH2025 Kayla Kinkel [33:30]. |
| [33:34] | Shot by HCFH2025 Katelyn Klotz, SAVE Lauren Bachner. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [34:19] | HCFH2025 substitution: Caroline Aspuru for Dani Hand. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| [36:53] | NAZARETH substitution: MacKenzie Dixson for Kristina Fisher. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [38:20] | Shot by NAZARETH Michaela Cushman, SAVE Ava Reynolds. |
| [38:28] | Shot by NAZARETH Isabel Porterfield, SAVE Ava Reynolds. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [39:44] | NAZARETH substitution: Hanna Barrett for Michaela Cushman. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [40:38] | HCFH2025 substitution: Dani Hand for Erica Leeson. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [42:10] | NAZARETH substitution: Kristina Fisher for MacKenzie Dixson. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| [42:44] | NAZARETH substitution: Michaela Cushman for Hannah Janes. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Nazareth. |
| | Foul on Hartwick College. |
| | End of period [45:00]. |