| 4th Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 4th period [15:00]. |
| [15:00] | Faceoff Cade Bourcy vs Owen Ryan won by UTICA, [15:00] Ground ball pickup by UTICA Michael Mecca. |
| [13:48] | Shot by UTICA Lucas Donahue BLOCKED. |
| [13:37] | Shot by UTICA Nolan Shea, SAVE Kaiden Johnson. |
| [13:34] | Ground ball pickup by HARTWICK Harry Rubin. |
| [13:24] | Clear attempt by HARTWICK good. |
| [13:14] | Turnover by HARTWICK Liam McManus (caused by Michael Mecca). |
| [12:46] | Clear attempt by UTICA good. |
| [12:09] | Turnover by UTICA Ryan Considine (caused by Eddie Hughes). |
| [12:06] | Clear attempt by HARTWICK good. |
| [12:01] | GOAL by HARTWICK Colin August, Assist by Mason Adams. |
| Utica University 12, Hartwick College 9 |
| [12:01] | Penalty on UTICA Nolan Shea (SLASHING/1:00) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [12:01] | Faceoff Chase Nappi vs Owen Ryan won by UTICA, [12:01] Ground ball pickup by UTICA Colin Musso. |
| [10:41] | Turnover by UTICA. |
| [10:23] | Clear attempt by HARTWICK good. |
| [09:47] | Shot by HARTWICK Spencer Hogaboom, SAVE Jake Bowen. |
| [09:41] | GOAL by HARTWICK Colin August. |
| Utica University 12, Hartwick College 10 |
| [09:41] | Faceoff Chase Nappi vs Owen Ryan won by UTICA, [09:41] Ground ball pickup by UTICA Chase Nappi. |
| [09:04] | Shot by UTICA Lucas Donahue, SAVE Kaiden Johnson. |
| [08:49] | Clear attempt by HARTWICK good. |
| [08:05] | Shot by HARTWICK Matthew Paquette, SAVE Jake Bowen. |
| [07:53] | Clear attempt by UTICA good. |
| [06:50] | Shot by UTICA Logan Waterman, SAVE Kaiden Johnson. |
| [06:43] | Shot by UTICA Nolan Shea WIDE RIGHT. |
| [06:10] | Shot by HARTWICK Spencer Hogaboom BLOCKED. |
| [05:55] | Foul on UTICA. |
| [05:47] | GOAL by HARTWICK Colin August. |
| Utica University 12, Hartwick College 11 |
| [05:47] | Faceoff Cade Bourcy vs Owen Ryan won by HARTWICK, [05:47] Ground ball pickup by HARTWICK Henry Tobin. |
| [05:16] | Shot by HARTWICK Colin August HIGH. |
| [04:48] | Shot by HARTWICK Colin August WIDE LEFT. |
| [04:31] | Shot by HARTWICK Colby Simonetti WIDE RIGHT. |
| [04:28] | Penalty on UTICA Vincent Bernardo (HOLDING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [04:13] | Turnover by HARTWICK Colin August. |
| [04:06] | Clear attempt by UTICA failed. |
| [03:46] | GOAL by HARTWICK Liam McManus, Assist by Spencer Hogaboom. |
| Utica University 12, Hartwick College 12 |
| [03:46] | Faceoff Chase Nappi vs Owen Ryan won by UTICA (on faceoff violation). |
| [02:31] | GOAL by UTICA Ryan Hollenbeck, Assist by Michael Reid. |
| Utica University 13, Hartwick College 12 |
| [02:31] | Faceoff Cade Bourcy vs Owen Ryan won by HARTWICK (on faceoff violation). |
| [01:52] | Shot by HARTWICK Matthew Paquette, SAVE Jake Bowen. |
| [01:40] | Clear attempt by UTICA good. |
| [00:48] | Penalty on HARTWICK Eddie Hughes (SLASHING/1:00) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [00:27] | Timeout by UTICA. |
| [00:27] | AJ Saragossi at goalie for HARTWICK. |