| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi23 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi23 | PENALTY GRO false start (Scott Fraser) 5 yards to the THI28. |
| Gro | 1-15 | on Thi28 | Josh Ehst pass complete to Cody Gustafson for 7 yards to the THI21 (Justin Logan;Hunter Knapczyk). |
| Gro | 2-8 | on Thi21 | Zach Trusky rush for 17 yards to the THI4, 1ST DOWN GRO (Darnell Jordan). |
| Gro | 1-G | on Thi04 | Zach Trusky rush for 1 yard to the THI3 (Jordan Volpe;Andrew Plowden). |
| Gro | 2-G | on Thi03 | Zach Trusky rush for 3 yards to the THI0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:23. |
| | | Nick Morrow kick attempt good. |
| Grove City 42, Thiel 0 |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 72 yards, TOP 4:42 |
| | | Eddie Bianco kickoff 61 yards to the THI4, Justin Logan return 11 yards to the THI15 (Justin DeMild;C. Freyermuth). |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi15 | THIEL drive start at 13:13. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi15 | Owen Trumbull pass incomplete to Jake Reddick. |
| Thi | 2-10 | on Thi15 | PENALTY THI false start (Andre Rodgers) 5 yards to the THI10. |
| Thi | 2-15 | on Thi10 | Owen Trumbull pass incomplete to Andre Rodgers, dropped pass. |
| Thi | 3-15 | on Thi10 | Owen Trumbull pass incomplete to Chase Lawler. |
| Thi | 4-15 | on Thi10 | Jake Reddick punt 10 yards to the THI20, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 0:33 |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi20 | GROVE CITY drive start at 12:40. |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi20 | Logan Pfeuffer pass incomplete to Nick Gustafson. |
| Gro | 2-10 | on Thi20 | Logan Pfeuffer pass complete to Ryan Heckathorn for 16 yards to the THI4, 1ST DOWN GRO (Randall Miller;Donovan Lindsey). |
| Gro | 1-G | on Thi04 | Timeout Thiel, clock 12:10. |
| Gro | 1-G | on Thi04 | Logan Pfeuffer pass incomplete to Nick Gustafson. |
| Gro | 2-G | on Thi04 | Shay Aitken rush for 4 yards to the THI0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:59. |
| | | Nick Morrow kick attempt good. |
| Grove City 49, Thiel 0 |
| | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 0:41 |
| | | T. Stevenson kickoff 65 yards to the THI0, touchback. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi20 | THIEL drive start at 11:59. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi20 | THI ball on THI25. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi25 | Kaleb Donor rush for loss of 3 yards to the THI22 (Noah Yeck;Tim Gibson). |
| Thi | 2-13 | on Thi22 | Marlon Brown rush for 1 yard to the THI23 (Justin DeMild;Kobe Bonanno). |
| Thi | 3-12 | on Thi23 | Marlon Brown pass incomplete to Jake Reddick (Patrick Mark). |
| Thi | 4-12 | on Thi23 | Jake Reddick punt 12 yards to the THI35, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 1:35 |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi35 | GROVE CITY drive start at 10:24. |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi35 | Logan Pfeuffer pass complete to Augie Lienert for 2 yards to the THI33 (J. Pletcher). |
| Gro | 2-8 | on Thi33 | Shay Aitken rush for 15 yards to the THI18, 1ST DOWN GRO (Ryan Selig;Malik Beckford). |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi18 | Logan Pfeuffer rush for 9 yards to the THI9 (X. Goodwin). |
| Gro | 2-1 | on Thi09 | Logan Pfeuffer pass incomplete to Hunter Crown. |
| Gro | 3-1 | on Thi09 | Shay Aitken rush for 9 yards to the THI0, 1ST DOWN GRO, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:12. |
| | | Nick Morrow kick attempt good. |
| Grove City 56, Thiel 0 |
| | Drive: 5 plays, 35 yards, TOP 2:12 |
| | | T. Stevenson kickoff 62 yards to the THI3, out-of-bounds, THI ball on THI35. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi35 | THIEL drive start at 08:12. |
| Thi | 1-10 | on Thi35 | Tyler Maddox rush for 3 yards to the THI38 (Justin DeMild;Kobe Bonanno). |
| Thi | 2-7 | on Thi38 | Tyler Maddox rush for 6 yards to the THI44 (Justin DeMild;Marcus Woodford). |
| Thi | 3-1 | on Thi44 | Tyler Maddox rush for no gain to the THI44 (Jason Muench;Tim Gibson). |
| Thi | 4-1 | on Thi44 | Jake Reddick punt 4 yards to the THI48, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 2:27 |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi48 | GROVE CITY drive start at 05:45. |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi48 | Logan Pfeuffer pass incomplete to Hunter Crown, dropped pass. |
| Gro | 2-10 | on Thi48 | Logan Pfeuffer pass complete to Hunter Crown for 5 yards to the THI43 (Raymond Jackson). |
| Gro | 3-5 | on Thi43 | Joseph DeLuca rush for 8 yards to the THI35, 1ST DOWN GRO (Thomas Wilson). |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi35 | Sean Matthews rush for 10 yards to the THI25, 1ST DOWN GRO (Ryan Selig;Raymond Jackson). |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi25 | Sean Matthews rush for 2 yards to the THI23 (Jared Beers). |
| Gro | 2-8 | on Thi23 | Joseph DeLuca rush for 11 yards to the THI12, 1ST DOWN GRO (Mario Demma;Raymond Jackson). |
| Gro | 1-10 | on Thi12 | Joseph DeLuca rush for 6 yards to the THI6 (Mario Demma). |
| Gro | 2-4 | on Thi06 | Timeout Grove City, clock 01:16. |
| Gro | 2-4 | on Thi06 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the THI7. |
| Gro | 3-5 | on Thi07 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the THI8. |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 40 yards, TOP 4:29 |
